The Serpent and the Moon:
Two Rivals for the Love
of a Renaissance King
By Her Royal Highness
Princess Michael of Kent
Touchstone, 405 pages, $42.50
Overcrowded royal marriages hold a particularly enduring
fascination no matter in what century they take place,
as British royal Princess Michael of Kent ably demonstrates
in her latest work, The Serpent and the Moon.
Set in France during the first half of the 16th century,
the book charts the lives and relationships among King
Henri II of France; his wife, Catherine de Medici;
and Henri's lover, Diane de Poitiers.
From the outset, the author declares her enormous
admiration and a sense of personal connection with
Diane, "the Moon." Her antipathy for "the
Serpent" -- Catherine de Medici -- is also strong.
Personal favouritism notwithstanding, the author's
confidence and passion for her subject have inspired
a hugely entertaining book.
While the story of the three protagonists and the
vicissitudes they faced is the stuff of High Renaissance
drama, the author is careful to give the compelling
narrative a lucid and well-described mis en scène.
Diane was born in 1499; her mother and Catherine de
Medici's were cousins. The young noblewoman was placed
in the household of Queen Claude, consort to François
I, the great Renaissance king. At 15, she married the
brilliant, 55-year-old widower, Louis de Brézé,
one of the richest, most important and ugliest men
in the kingdom. It was an excellent if perhaps physically
unappetizing match for the blond, blue-eyed teenager,
who was already drawing attention to herself not only
for her beauty, but for an elegant self-possession
that far exceeded her years.
Henri and Catherine, his future wife, were born within
a few weeks of each other in 1519. Catherine was orphaned
only days after her birth and Henri lost his mother
when he was 4. Both children then suffered periods
of imprisonment, being held hostage in separate conflicts.
Catherine was incarcerated in Florence while Henri
endured four years of hardship in various Spanish fortresses.
When at last he was released, Henri had changed from
a cheerful boy into a sullen and withdrawn teenager.
Diane, now widowed, made it her mission, at the King's
request, to draw his least favourite son out. Her kindness,
patience and humour soon made their mark on this awkward
boy, and it is no wonder the prince became ensorcelled
by her.
A pawn in strategic plans for the Italian peninsula
between Pope Clement VII and François I brought
the arrival of the non-royal Catherine de Medici as
a bride for Henri. This did not change the prince's
feeling for "his lady" Diane. He simply ignored
the dumpy little bride, who, having suffered much the
same miserable childhood as her husband, loved him
desperately from the moment she met him. This was her
tragedy; believing she had found a family and home,
the clever but physically unattractive young woman
soon found herself supplanted by a sophisticated beauty.
When Henri acceded to the throne in 1547, he made
Diane richer than even she could ever have hoped; though
time had taken its toll on her famed beauty, her hold
on the king's heart remained as firm as ever. While
there is no evidence that she ever really tried to
influence him when it came to politics, Diane enjoyed
enormous powers of patronage and greatly enriched herself
and her kin.
The author highlights Diane's virtues, her fidelity
to Henri, her staunch support of Catholicism, her sublime
taste, her modern adherence to matters of hygiene and
a unique ability to appear cool and remote, as though
on another plane. Indeed, she promoted endless allegorical
references to herself as Diana, the chaste goddess
of the hunt, for that was precisely how she wished
to be seen.
The near-deification of Diane by Princess Michael
is sometimes hard to swallow, particularly as there
is a corresponding demonizing of Catherine. For example,
the author divines that when Catherine was silent she
must have been hatching evil schemes. It is also worth
noting that Diane's hatred of Protestants might have
had something to do with the fact that the "heretics" called
her a whore. In truth, Diane was an extremely smart
cookie with good looks, extraordinary taste, a head
for figures and a generous lover.
Little credit is given to the humiliated queen and
her dignified acceptance of the mistress's supremacy.
The king insensitively had their entwined initials, "H & D," carved
and painted wherever he could, and Catherine knew that
to complain would gain her nothing. If she accepted "our
friend" -- as the king called Diane -- she would
at least be pleasing her husband.
Finally the triangle, so long established, became
an entirely unremarkable feature of court life. Each
woman conceived a healthy respect for the other; Diane
took care of the Queen when she was ill or pregnant,
and Catherine always behaved with great politesse to
her rival. Both also knew that it would be better not
to destabilize a formula that might expose the king
to unknown predators. The idea that Diane protected
Catherine out of goodness to the Queen is nonsense;
it was to ward off a beautiful young royal replacement
who might not tolerate the liaison with Henri.
This is book is a cornucopia of fascinating, well-researched
period detail, much of it about the exquisite paintings,
sculptures and buildings commissioned by Diane, notably
her glorious Renaissance palace at Anet. Added to the
fortune in cash, jewels and other treasures Henri gave
his mistress was the extraordinary Chateau of Chenonceau,
a place also much desired by Catherine, and the snub
provoked a rare but bitter cry from the Queen.
After Henri's sudden and tragic death in 1559 in a
jousting accident, Catherine, far from being vengeful,
simply traded her own less attractive but more valuable
estate of Chaumont with Diane for Chenonceau, and banished
her from court. The mistress knew that her days of
power were over. Diane might have been queen of Henri's
heart, but Catherine was Queen of France.
Leonie Frieda is the author of the recent biography
Catherine de Medici. She lives in London.